Season Two · Part One · Episode 5 of 24
Margaret and Renee find the same pattern from two different directions.
Margaret had built the list twice, hoping the second version would look different from the first. It didn’t.
She’d started it the week after the leadership meeting, when Renee said the number out loud, three million dollars, at risk because of everything Marcus had never done. It had stayed with Margaret longer than she expected. Not the number. The sentence beneath it. We celebrated exactly what we should have been worried about.
She’d pulled ten years of records and marked every associate who’d been given real, unsupervised client contact before making partner, the ones invited to the dinner rather than told about it afterward, looped into strategy rather than handed the outcome. Nine names. She cross-referenced each one against the partner who’d first brought them in.
The pattern wasn’t about billables. All nine had been strong associates, the kind who’d have eventually made partner on the work alone. What the list actually showed was who got there faster and why.
Six of the nine had been personally sponsored by a partner who, on paper and often almost in person, had once been them. Same regional background. Same kind of undergraduate, same clerkship track, same easy conversational rhythm that let a partner see an earlier version of the same path standing in an elevator and think, without ever framing it as a decision: I should bring that one along.
It wasn’t malice. After ten years of watching it unfold in slow motion, Margaret was certain of that. It was just what comfort looks like when nobody’s asked to examine it.
◆
Renee knocked on Margaret’s open door at five-thirty. It felt like an interruption.
“Do you have ten minutes?” Renee said, already seated with a folder under one arm. “I’ve been building something, and I have a feeling you’ve been building the same thing.”
She turned her folder around on Margaret’s desk. A list. Nine names, though, Margaret noticed after a second, not quite the same nine; Renee had gone back fourteen years and cross-referenced origination credit and second-name engagement records rather than staffing memos. Different data. Same shape.
“I got curious after the meeting,” Renee said. “I wanted to know whether what happened with Marcus was really an isolated planning failure or just the most expensive version of something we do constantly and never examine.”
“And?”
“It’s not isolated,” Renee said. “We’ve been running an entirely informal sponsorship system for as long as I’ve been here. It works, when it works, exactly as informal systems always do. It rewards resemblance and calls it instinct.”
◆
Margaret thought of David Chen, who wasn’t on either list, and said as much.
Renee nodded slowly. “David’s the control group,” she said. “Nobody saw a younger version of themselves in him early on. So he learned the unwritten rules the hard way, five years later than the associates who had someone translating them in real time. He’s spent his whole career being quietly excellent in spite of that, not because anyone made it easier.”
“He’d tell you he doesn’t resent it,” Margaret said.
“He wouldn’t have to resent it for it to have cost him five years,” Renee said. “That’s the part that’s hard to say out loud in a room full of partners, each of whom believes, mostly sincerely, that they chose their protégés on merit. Every one of them can tell you exactly why the person they picked deserved it. None of them can tell you why they never looked twice at the associate two doors down, who deserved it just as much and simply didn’t remind them of anyone.”
She said it without heat. Margaret had worked with Renee long enough to know that the flatness was deliberate, the same control that made her the partner leadership called in when a matter was politically sensitive enough that anger, even justified anger, would only get in the way of being believed.
◆
“So what do we do with this?” Margaret asked.
Renee closed the folder. “Nothing yet. Not until there are more than two lists, built independently by two people who already suspected something. I want the compensation committee’s origination-credit history to go further back, and I want to know if anyone’s tried to fix this before and quietly given up.”
She stood, then paused at the door. “Marcus’s clients not transferring is the version of this everyone can see, because it comes with a dollar figure attached. This version doesn’t come with a dollar figure. It just comes with nine names, and then, eventually, whoever the next nine would have been if we’d bothered to look.”
Margaret stayed at her desk a while after Renee left, thinking about Kevin, who wasn’t on either list, and about how much of what happened to a career came down to who happened to be standing nearby the day someone decided, without quite deciding, who they’d bring along.
← Episode 4The MSL SagaEpisode 6 →
Susan B. Silverman works with mid-sized law firm leaders on the problems this season dramatizes: succession, sponsorship, and the client relationships that never get handed down. Book a free consultation.
The MSL Saga™, MLARD™, and the 85/15 Model™ are trademarks of Susan B. Silverman Consulting. The MSL Saga and all episodes © 2026 Susan B. Silverman Consulting. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution is prohibited.
