Season Two · Part One · Episode 3 of 24
Kevin says the sentence out loud for the first time, and it doesn’t go away.
Kevin Patel knocked on Anna’s open door at six-forty, which was unusual because Kevin never came by after six.
“Do you have a minute?” he said, in the tone of someone who had already decided the answer didn’t matter because he was going to say it regardless.
Anna closed her laptop. “Of course. Close the door if you’d like.”
He did. They went back a few years, to a qui tam case where he’d been the partner checking her work, and hers was the door he’d picked.
Kevin sat, then stood, then sat again. “I keep thinking about that call with Walt,” he said.
“It went fine,” Anna said, because it had, technically. Walt hadn’t left, and nobody had made a mistake.
“It went well,” Kevin agreed. “That’s the part I can’t stop thinking about. I did everything right, and it still felt like watching myself fail at something I couldn’t name.”
◆
He talked for a while without much shape to it. It was the first time he’d said any of it out loud. He’d been put on the equity track nine months ago. He’d billed more hours than almost anyone in his class for six straight years. Clients trusted his work. Partners trusted his work. Nobody had ever told him his work wasn’t enough.
“And now everyone keeps saying the same word to me,” he said. “Business development. Like it’s a task. Like it’s on a checklist next to ‘file the motion,’ and it’s just a matter of getting to it.”
“Has anyone actually shown you how?” Anna asked. “Not told you to do it. Shown you.”
Kevin thought about it long enough for the answer to be obvious before he said it. “No. I think everyone assumes it’s a personality thing. Either you have it or you’re the kind of lawyer who doesn’t. And I’ve spent nine years proving I’m not the kind of lawyer who doesn’t have it.”
“So what happens if you can’t figure it out?” Anna asked as gently as the question allowed.
“Then, in five years, I’m exactly where the equity partners started calling service partners two years ago,” Kevin said. “Technically a partner. Structurally stuck. Eventually, somebody like Renee sits me down and kindly asks whether I’ve thought about what I really want from the next chapter of my career.”
He said the last part in a voice that wasn’t quite his own, a partner’s voice, borrowed for that sentence.
◆
Anna recognized the shape of it before she could name why. It took her a moment to place it: it was Sam’s resignation email, three years and a lifetime ago, the one with no complaints or requests, just careful gratitude and a decision already made. Sam hadn’t been angry either. He’d just quietly concluded that no one was going to explain the rest of it to him and had stopped waiting.
“You’re not there yet,” Anna said. “You’re just scared you’ll end up there.”
“I’m scared nobody’s going to notice until I do,” Kevin said. “Marcus got a party. Do you know what happens to the partner who never builds a book? Nothing. No party. Just fewer matters, a little quieter each year, until it’s not really a question anymore.”
Anna didn’t have an answer for that, and she didn’t pretend she did. What she had instead was a question she hadn’t planned to ask, the same one she’d carried for most of her fifth year before anyone had bothered to answer it for her.
“Who taught you the rest of it?” she asked. “The stuff you do know, like judgment, ownership, and running a matter without someone checking your work.”
“Ellen’s program,” Kevin said. “Secondhand. I mentored two associates through MLARD and learned more from the materials than they did. Susan’s system.”
“And before that?”
“Nobody,” Kevin said. “I figured it out by watching, guessing, and getting some of it wrong in private, where nobody would see.”
Anna sat with that. “So the firm already knows how to do this,” she said slowly. “It already built the thing that would fix what you’re describing. It just built it for one stage and stopped.”
◆
Kevin didn’t have anything to say to that, and Anna didn’t press the issue. It wasn’t hers to fix. She wasn’t a partner, didn’t run compensation committees, and couldn’t design whatever came after MLARD, even if she could now clearly see that something needed to. But she recognized the feeling in the room because she’d sat in it herself, in a different chair, a different year, asking a version of the same unanswerable question.
“I’m glad you said it out loud,” she told him, meaning it.
“Please don’t repeat any of this,” Kevin said, standing, already looking less like a man who’d confessed something and more like a partner again, as the door was about to reopen.
“I won’t,” Anna said. She would think about it for the rest of the week instead, not repeat it exactly, but not forget it either.
◆
Alone in his office afterward, Kevin opened the client list he’d been handed, along with his notes from his equity track conversation from six weeks earlier. The memo had called it prospective relationships to cultivate. Eleven names. No further instructions.
He had read excellent legal writing every day of his career and had never once been handed a document that told him less than this one did.
He closed the file. He didn’t have the first move, and for the first time in nine years of always knowing the next step, no amount of preparation would produce it.
← Episode 2The MSL SagaEpisode 4 →
Susan B. Silverman works with mid-sized law firm leaders on the problems this season dramatizes: succession, sponsorship, and the client relationships that never get handed down. Book a free consultation.
The MSL Saga™, MLARD™, and the 85/15 Model™ are trademarks of Susan B. Silverman Consulting. The MSL Saga and all episodes © 2026 Susan B. Silverman Consulting. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution is prohibited.
